How to use this calculator
- 1 Enter the lump sum you are offered and the monthly pension you would receive.
- 2 Enter your retirement age and the age you plan to live to. Pension years are the difference.
- 3 Add any yearly cost-of-living increase, or leave it at 0 for a flat pension.
- 4 Enter the rate your money could earn elsewhere, then compare the present value with the lump sum.
Lump sum or monthly pension?
Some employers and pension schemes let you choose. You can take a single payment now, or a steady income for the rest of your life. Both choices can be fair, but the right one depends on your needs, your health and the rate your money could earn.
The key idea is present value. A payment far in the future is worth less than the same amount today, because money today can earn a return. So this tool adds up all the future pension payments, discounts each one, and compares the total with the lump sum.
How the comparison works
You enter the lump sum, the monthly pension, your retirement age and the age you plan to live to. The gap between the two ages sets the number of pension years. Also, you can add a yearly cost-of-living increase.
Then you pick a discount rate. This is what your money could earn each year elsewhere. A higher rate makes future payments look smaller, which favours the lump sum. However, a lower rate favours the pension.
How the discount rate changes the answer
The table uses a $300,000 lump sum against $1,500 a month for 25 years (ages 65 to 90). The only change is the discount rate, and in the last row, a 2% yearly rise in the pension.
| Discount rate | Pension worth today | Better choice on these numbers |
|---|---|---|
| 3% | $317,723.41 | Pension, by $17,723.41 |
| 4% | $286,316.22 | Lump sum, by $13,683.78 |
| 5% | $259,453.54 | Lump sum, by $40,546.46 |
| 4%, pension rises 2% a year | $352,423.67 | Pension, by $52,423.67 |
What the break-even rate tells you
The break-even rate is the discount rate at which both choices are worth the same. In the example, it is 3.54%. If you believe your money can safely earn more than that, the lump sum looks better. If you expect less, then the pension looks better.
A rising pension has a higher break-even rate. For example, with a 2% yearly increase, the example breaks even at 5.51%.
Things the numbers can’t show
Money is only part of the choice, so think about these points before you decide:
- Living longer. A pension keeps paying if you live past your planned age. A lump sum can run out.
- Inflation. A flat pension buys less each year. See how prices change with the inflation calculator.
- Survivors. Some pensions pay a spouse after you die. Others stop. Ask your plan.
- Tax and rules. Tax on lump sums and pensions differs by country, and so do rules for transfers.
- The provider. Check how secure the pension scheme is where you live.
Next steps
First, to see how a lump sum could be spent over time, try the annuity payout calculator. Then, for your wider plan, the retirement calculator turns savings into income. The present value calculator explains the discounting idea on its own.
The formula
Present value of the pension
PV = Σ P × (1 + c)^⌊(k − 1) ÷ 12⌋ × (1 + r)^(−k ÷ 12), for k = 1 … 12 × years
- PV
- present value of all pension payments, at present value
- P
- monthly pension in the first year
- c
- yearly cost-of-living increase, as a decimal
- r
- discount or investment rate per year, as a decimal
- k
- month number, counting from 1
Monthly income from the lump sum
Payment = L × i ÷ (1 − (1 + i)^−n), where i = (1 + r)^(1/12) − 1
- L
- lump sum offered
- i
- monthly rate equivalent to r
- n
- number of months in the pension (years × 12)
Worked example
A $300,000 lump sum against $1,500 a month for 25 years
- 1.Pension years: 90 − 65 = 25, so n = 300 months
- 2.Monthly rate equivalent: i = 1.04^(1/12) − 1 = 0.3274%
- 3.Present value of $1,500 a month for 300 months at 4% ≈ $286,316.22
- 4.Difference: $286,316.22 − $300,000 = −$13,683.78
- 5.Lump sum income: $300,000 × 0.3274% ÷ (1 − 1.003274^−300) ≈ $1,571.69 a month
At 4%, the lump sum is worth $13,683.78 more than the pension at present value. It could pay about $1,571.69 a month for 25 years.
Frequently asked questions
How do I compare a pension and a lump sum?
Find the present value of all the pension payments at a sensible discount rate. Then compare it with the lump sum. Whichever is larger is worth more today on those assumptions.
What discount rate should I use?
Use a rate close to what you could earn on a similar, low-risk investment after tax. A higher rate makes future payments look less valuable, which favours the lump sum.
Why does a cost-of-living increase matter?
A pension that rises each year can be worth much more than a flat one over a long retirement. Enter the increase your plan promises, or 0 if it does not rise.
What is the break-even rate?
It is the discount rate at which the pension and the lump sum are worth the same today. If your own expected return is above it, the lump sum usually wins on these numbers.
Does this include tax or survivor benefits?
No. The figures are before tax and ignore survivor benefits, inflation beyond the increase you enter, and early-payment penalties. Ask your plan administrator for the exact terms.
Sources
Last reviewed by the GridCalculators team.